Beren, whey did you have Bearclaw take the heavy flail, when I already had him take the magic heavy mace? He doesn’t need two bludgeoning weapons…
Greywind, I am sorry, I must have misread your post or remembered it wrong when I wrote my own, I was sure that Samuel asked for one of the magic bludgeoning weapons, which he obviously didn’t. The way he said it however makes it possible for Lighthawk and Bearclaw to have misunderstand him as well (if they didn’t really paid attention to where he was pointing).
I know Samuel wanted the amulet, but it is just as useful for Sul, and since Bearclaw likes her and is quite protective towards her it seemed natural for him to give her the amulet. (Especially if he thought that Samuel wanted one of the magic weapons as well)
I suggest that you make Samuel accept the magic greataxe
and asks Bearclaw for the heavy flail as well, you can then later sell the greataxe and by an amulet of natural armor (that is if you have not already gotten one from the slavers)I think I will be more often in the front line than Sul; at least that's how it's been before.
That’s mostly a coincidence, Sul is a pretty effective front line fighter and should be as much in the front as Samuel (she will also need to, now that Myroj and Roadamer are gone) And what should I do with another magic weapon? I have already a good one. Sure I can have the greataxe for the zombies and the greatclub (or whatever) for the skeletons, but I feel there's no point playing golf caddy and have a weapon for every occasion.
It is generally a good idea to have a secondary weapon, because there is plenty of ways you can lose your primary one. 3 melee weapons may however be going a little overboard…